Saturday, October 5, 2013

Best albums of the 2000s - Rolling Stone vs The People redux

In July 2012 I started publishing a series of stories comparing Rolling Stone magazine's list of the best 500 albums of all time with the top 500 albums on Rate Your Music (RYM). RYM is my favourite music discovery tool. It is a dedicated, crows sourced rating site.

I just discovered Rolling Stone's list of the best albums of the 2000s. I thought it would be interesting to repeat the analysis for this recent decade.

You can find the Rolling Stone list here. I generated the RYM list on 6 July 2014. For the record, here it is:


1
.
Radiohead 
Kid A 
2 . Arcade Fire  Funeral 
3 . Godspeed You Black Emperor!  Lift Yr. Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven! 
4 . Radiohead  In Rainbows 
5 . Opeth  Blackwater Park 
6 . Madvillain  Madvillainy 
7 . Wilco  Yankee Hotel Foxtrot 
8 . Tool  Lateralus 
9 . Radiohead  Amnesiac 
10 . Sufjan Stevens  Illinois 
11 . Interpol  Turn On the Bright Lights 
12 . Sigur Rós  ()
13 . Modest Mouse  The Moon & Antarctica 
14 . J Dilla  Donuts 
15 . Queens of the Stone Age  Songs for the Deaf 
16 . At the Drive-In  Relationship of Command 
17 . The Flaming Lips  Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots 
18 . Portishead  Third 
19 . The National  Boxer 
20 . Isis Panopticon 
21 . Agalloch  The Mantle 
22 . The Strokes  Is This It 
23 . Agalloch  Ashes Against the Grain 
24 . Electric Wizard  Dopethrone 
25 . Tom Waits  Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers & Bastards 
26 . Joanna Newsom  Ys 
27 . Radiohead  Hail to the Thief 
28 . Porcupine Tree  In Absentia 
29 . The Mars Volta  De-Loused in the Comatorium 
30 . Converge  Jane Doe 
31 . Boards of Canada Geogaddi 
32 . Björk  Vespertine 
33 . The Microphones  The Glow Pt. 2 
34 . Unwound  Leaves Turn Inside You 
35 . Clint Mansell  The Fountain 
36 . Broken Social Scene  You Forgot It in People 
37 . The National  Alligator 
38 . Opeth  Ghost Reveries 
39 . Yann Tiersen  Amélie 
40 . Arcade Fire  Neon Bible 
41 . Sigur Ros Takk 
42 . Immolation  Close to a World Below 
43 . The Avalanches  Since I Left You 
44 . Opeth  Damnation 
45 . Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds  No More Shall We Part 
46 . Deltron 3030  Deltron 3030 
47 . Johnny Cash  American IV: The Man Comes Around 
48 . Panda Bear  Person Pitch 
49 . 山岡晃 [Akira Yamaoka]  Silent Hill 2: Original Soundtrack 
50 . Daft Punk  Discovery 
51 . Mastodon  Leviathan 
52 . Coil  The Ape of Naples 
53 . Fugazi  The Argument 
54 . Animal Collective  Merriweather Post Pavilion 
55 . Boris  Boris at Last -Feedbacker- 
56 . Mastodon  Crack the Skye 
57 . Ulver  Perdition City 
58 . Burial Untrue 
59 . Venetian Snares  Rossz csillag alatt született 
60 . Jay-Z  The Blueprint 
61 . Isis  Oceanic 
62 . Neurosis  A Sun That Never Sets 
63 . Mitch Hedberg  Mitch All Together 
64 . Cannibal Ox  The Cold Vein 
65 . The White Stripes  Elephant 
66 . Bob Dylan  The Bootleg Series Vol. 8: Tell Tale Signs - Rare and Unreleased 1989-2006 
67 . Johnny Cash  American III: Solitary Man 
68 . Porcupine Tree  Lightbulb Sun 
69 . PJ Harvey  Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea 
70 . Porcupine Tree  Deadwing 
71 . Primordial  To the Nameless Dead 
72 . Kanye West  The College Dropout 
73 . Bon Iver  For Emma, Forever Ago 
74 . Godspeed You! Black Emperor  Yanqui U.X.O. 
75 . Howard Shore  The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring 
76 . Stars of the Lid  The Tired Sounds of Stars of the Lid 
77 . Queens of the Stone Age  Rated R 
78 . Moonsorrow  Verisäkeet 
79 . Explosions in the Sky  The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place 
80 . Tim Hecker  Harmony in Ultraviolet 
81 . Morton Feldman  String Quartet No. 2 
82 . Sun Kil Moon Ghosts of the Great Highway 
83 . Deftones  White Pony 
84 . Ghostface Killah  Supreme Clientele 
85 . CunninLynguists  A Piece of Strange 
86 . The Roots  Game Theory 
87 . Animal Collective  Strawberry Jam 
88 . Neurosis  The Eye of Every Storm 
89 . LCD Soundsystem  Sound of Silver 
90 . Fleet Foxes  Fleet Foxes 
91 . Moonsorrow  Kivenkantaja 
92 . Yo La Tengo  And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out 
93 . Negură Bunget  OM 
94 . Tom Waits  Alice 
95 . Devin Townsend  Terria 
96 . Arcturus  The Sham Mirrors 
97 . Pain of Salvation  Remedy Lane 
98 . Pain of Salvation  The Perfect Element I 
99 . Vektor  Black Future 
100 . Brand New  The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me 

No comments:

Post a Comment